Copycat Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies Recipe

8

Now, here’s the thing. As much as I adore picking up a box on my Trader Joe’s run, there’s something so satisfying about recreating beloved snacks in my own kitchen. That’s why I set out to make the perfect copycat recipe for Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies! This homemade version lets you enjoy the warm, spiced flavor of cookie butter in the form of perfectly baked cookies—with each bite hitting that sweet spot between crunchy and creamy.

How to make Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies

Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies usually refer to a specific sweet treat made by Trader Joe’s that combines their famous cookie butter flavor into a cookie form—most commonly as Cookie Butter Sandwich Cookies.

Ingredients

For the Cookies (Shortbread Base):

• 1 cup unsalted butter (softened at room temperature)
• 1/2 cup powdered sugar
• 2 cups all-purpose flour
• 1/4 tsp salt
• 1 tsp vanilla extract

For the Filling:

• 1 cup cookie butter (you can use Trader Joe’s Speculoos Cookie Butter or any brand of cookie butter)
• 2-3 tbsp powdered sugar (optional, to thicken the filling for a firmer texture)

Instructions

Step 1: Make the Cookie Dough

1. Cream the butter and sugar: In a large mixing bowl, beat softened butter and powdered sugar together until light and fluffy. This will take about 2-3 minutes.
2. Add vanilla extract: Stir in the vanilla extract for a hint of flavor.
3. Combine dry ingredients: Gradually add the flour and salt to the butter mixture, mixing until a soft dough forms. Scrape down the sides as needed.
4. Chill the dough: Wrap the dough in plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 30 minutes to an hour. This makes it easier to roll and shape.

Step 2: Prepare the Filling

1. Mix the cookie butter: In a bowl, combine cookie butter and powdered sugar (optional) to create a slightly thicker, pipeable consistency. Set aside.

Step 3: Assemble the Cookies

1. Roll the dough: After chilling, roll the dough out onto a floured surface to about 1/8 to 1/4 inch thickness.
2. Shape the cookies: Use a round cookie cutter (or glass) to cut out even-sized circles. You’ll need two cookie rounds per cookie—one for the base and one for the top.
3. Add filling: Place a small dollop (about 1 tsp) of cookie butter filling in the center of one round. Gently place a second round over the filling and seal the edges by pressing lightly. You can even use a fork or crimper for a decorative edge.
4. Chill again (optional): To ensure the cookies hold their shape during baking, refrigerate the assembled cookies for another 15 minutes before baking.

Step 4: Bake the Cookies

1. Preheat your oven to 350°F (175°C).
2. Place the cookies on a parchment-lined baking sheet about 1 inch apart.
3. Bake for 12-15 minutes or until the edges are just lightly golden. Be careful not to overbake, as shortbread should remain buttery and tender.
4. Let the cookies cool completely on a wire rack before serving.

Tips to Perfect Your Cookies

• Don’t skip chilling the dough: Chilling prevents the dough from spreading too much in the oven and helps maintain that ideal cookie shape.
• Adjust cookie butter consistency if needed: If your cookie butter is too soft, adding powdered sugar or refrigerating it for a bit can firm it up for easier filling.
• Seal edges properly: Ensure the top and bottom cookie rounds are pressed together firmly. You can brush a tiny bit of water around the edges to help them stick together.
• Experiment with shapes: You can use festive cookie cutters or stamp designs onto the cookie tops for a decorative twist.
• Store properly: These cookies are best enjoyed fresh but can be stored in an airtight container for 4-5 days.

What to serve with

Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies are already delicious on their own, with their buttery shortbread base and creamy, spiced filling. But why stop there?

1. Coffee: The caramelized, cinnamon-y notes of cookie butter pair wonderfully with coffee. Whether you enjoy a hot latte, cappuccino, or cold brew, the slightly bitter edge of coffee really balances the sweetness of the Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies.

2. Hot Cocoa: Serve your cookies alongside a steaming mug of hot chocolate for the ultimate cozy treat. To kick it up a notch, stir a spoonful of cookie butter into the hot cocoa for an extra indulgent flavor!

3. Milk: You can never go wrong with a classic glass of milk—whether it’s whole milk, oat milk, or almond milk. It’s the perfect pairing for kids (and adults who are still kids at heart).

Ingredients Substitutes

If you’re planning to recreate Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies at home but don’t have all the exact ingredients, don’t worry! There are plenty of ingredient substitutes to keep the recipe delicious and functional.

1. Unsalted Butter

Butter is key to the rich, crumbly texture of shortbread cookies, but you can use substitutes if needed:

• Salted Butter: If you don’t have unsalted butter, you can use salted butter. Just reduce or omit the added salt in the recipe.
• Plant-Based Butter: For a dairy-free or vegan option, use plant-based butter made from coconut oil or avocado oil. Brands like Earth Balance work well as a substitute.
• Coconut Oil: Use solid (not melted) coconut oil for similar creaminess and fat content. Keep in mind that it may add a hint of coconut flavor to the cookies.

2. Powdered Sugar

Powdered sugar contributes to the tender texture of shortbread cookies.

• Granulated Sugar: If you don’t have powdered sugar, you can use granulated sugar, but the texture will be slightly grainier. You can also blend granulated sugar in a blender or food processor until it’s powdered.
• Brown Sugar: For a deeper, caramel-like sweetness, opt for brown sugar. This can slightly alter the cookie’s structure but adds amazing flavor.

3. All-Purpose Flour

Flour is the base structure for the cookies, but alternative flours can work:

• Whole Wheat Flour: Swap half the all-purpose flour with whole wheat flour for a more wholesome version. Just be prepared for a slightly denser cookie.
• Gluten-Free All-Purpose Flour: Use a gluten-free flour blend (like Bob’s Red Mill Gluten-Free Baking Flour) as a substitute for regular flour for gluten-free cookies.
• Almond Flour: Almond flour creates a denser but wonderfully nutty shortbread. It works best when mixed with a small portion of tapioca or coconut flour for structure.

4. Vanilla Extract

Vanilla enhances the flavor of the cookies, but you can substitute it with:

• Almond Extract: This will add a slightly nutty, fragrant twist to the cookies.
• Maple Syrup: For natural sweetness, use pure maple syrup to mimic the aromatic qualities of vanilla.
• Spices (Cinnamon or Nutmeg): In the absence of extract, spices can boost flavor and complement the cookie butter filling.

5. Salt

Salt balances the sweetness of the cookies. If you don’t have regular table salt:

• Kosher Salt: Adjust the amount since kosher salt is less dense than table salt.
• Sea Salt: Enhances flavor with a delicate, mineral-rich touch—use slightly less than the original amount.

Final Thoughts

These homemade Trader Joe’s Cookie Butter Cookies are perfect for sharing, gifting, or indulging with a cup of coffee. Each bite is packed with sweet, spiced goodness and a buttery crunch that rivals the original. Trust me—once you make these, they’ll quickly become a staple in your baking repertoire!

More Trader Joe’s Recipes:

• Copycat Trader Joe’s Kung Pao Chicken Recipe
• Copycat Trader Joe’s Chicken Fried Rice Recipe