Homemade Cutwater Popsicles Recipe

6

I’ve always been fascinated by ways to put a fun twist on classics. Imagine sipping a crisp margarita or rum cocktail—but instead of a glass, it’s served as a frosty popsicle, bursting with flavor. That’s exactly what we’re making today, and let me tell you, making the Cutwater Popsicles is way easier than you’d think!

How to make Cutwater Popsicles

Cutwater Popsicles are alcoholic frozen pops made by Cutwater Spirits, created by turning their canned cocktails into ice pops that you freeze and eat like a popsicle.

Ingredients

Base Ingredients:

• 1 cup Cutwater Spirits Alcohol (or your preferred spirit):
  • Tequila for Margarita flavors
  • Vodka for Mule-inspired popsicles
  • Rum for tropical varieties
  • Gin for fruity or botanical twists
• 2 cups fruit juice or soda (Choose a complementary mixer based on your spirit):
• Lime juice with simple syrup for Margarita popsicles
• Ginger beer for a Moscow Mule-inspired flavor
• Cola for Rum & Cola popsicles
• Melon juice for Gin Melon freshness

Additional Ingredients:

• Fresh fruit slices (optional, to enhance texture and flavor)
• Lime wedges, mango chunks, or berries work wonderfully.
• Simple syrup (to balance acidity and sweetness, depending on your base mix), about 2–4 tablespoons.
• Optional garnish: Edible glitter, salt for margaritas, or a splash of bitters.

Supplies:

• Popsicle molds or small paper cups
• Popsicle sticks
• Measuring cup
• A mixing bowl

Instructions

1. Measure out the alcohol (1 cup) and mixer (2 cups). Keep in mind that the alcohol is potent, so keeping the ratio around 2:1 (mixer to alcohol) ensures the popsicles freeze properly and taste balanced.
2. In a bowl, combine the alcohol, mixer, simple syrup, and any additional flavorings like fruit juice or bitters. Stir thoroughly to blend the flavors.
3. If you’re adding fresh fruit slices, place them directly into the popsicle molds for a fun visual touch and added texture.
4. Carefully pour the liquid mixture into the popsicle molds, leaving a small amount of space at the top for expansion during freezing.
5. Add a popsicle stick to each mold. (If using paper cups, place a layer of plastic wrap on top and poke the sticks through to keep them centered.)
6. Freeze for at least 6–8 hours, preferably overnight, until completely solid.
7. To unmold popsicles, briefly run warm water over the outside of the molds to loosen them.

Tips for Perfect Cutwater Popsicles

• Watch Your Alcohol Content: Alcohol doesn’t freeze as solidly as other ingredients. Keep the ratio of alcohol to mixer at about 1:2 or lower to prevent slushy popsicles.
• Experiment with Flavors: Mix and match spirits with unique fruity mixers—like pineapple juice with rum or grapefruit soda with vodka—to craft custom combinations.
• Add Fresh Garnishes: Slices of citrus, berries, or herbs (like mint or basil) not only look fancy but boost the flavor when frozen.
• Use High-Quality Spirits: Since the alcohol is central to the flavor, using good-quality spirits (like Cutwater Tequila or Rum) makes all the difference.
• Label Your Popsicles: If you’re making multiple flavors, use small tags or stickers on your molds to label the varieties. This way, you can quickly grab your favorite!
• Adjust Sweetness: Taste your mixture before freezing. Feel free to add more simple syrup if it needs to be sweeter or a splash of lime juice if it’s too sweet.

What to serve with

Cutwater Popsicles are a uniquely fun and boozy frozen treat that can easily steal the show at any gathering, but pairing them with the right foods and snacks will elevate your experience even further.

• Fresh Guacamole & Tortilla Chips: Great for complementing Margarita-inspired popsicles (like Lime or Mango flavors). The saltiness of the chips and creaminess of the guac balance the tartness of the frozen treat.
• Shrimp Cocktail: The zesty flavors of chilled shrimp with cocktail sauce are perfect alongside citrus-forward popsicles like Vodka Mule or Margarita Spirit Pops.
• Caprese Skewers: Fresh mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, and basil on skewers drizzled with balsamic glaze pair well with fruity popsicle flavors, especially Gin Melon or Vodka-based options.
• Mini Tacos or Nachos: Miniature tacos or loaded nachos are flavorful but light enough not to overwhelm the popsicles—a great match for Margarita flavors.

Ingredients Substitutes

Creating homemade Cutwater Popsicles is all about experimentation, but we don’t always have the exact ingredients on hand. Thankfully, there are plenty of clever substitutions you can make in the recipe without sacrificing flavor or texture.

1. Substitutes for Alcohol

Cutwater Popsicles are boozy treats, but what if you want to make a non-alcoholic version or swap spirits for a different flavor profile? Here are alternatives for the base alcohol:

Non-Alcoholic Options:

• Mocktail Bases: Swap alcohol for non-alcoholic spirit alternatives like Seedlip, Lyre’s, or Ritual Zero Proof to mimic cocktail flavors without the alcohol content.
• Fruit Juice: Replace alcohol with an equal portion of pure fruit juice for fun, kid-friendly popsicles. Mango, pineapple, or orange juice are great substitute for tropical recipes.
• Sparkling Water or Soda: Use sparkling water, tonic water, or ginger ale for a light, fizzy substitute that’s booze-free.

Alcohol Substitutions:

• Swapping Spirits: If your recipe calls for tequila, you can easily swap in vodka, rum, or gin, depending on the flavor profile you’d like to achieve.
• For tequila, try gin for a botanical twist in citrus-based popsicles.
• Replace rum with dark whiskey or spiced vodka for depth in tropical-inspired popsicles like Rum & Cola.

2. Juice or Mixer Substitutes

The choice of mixers can dramatically affect the flavor of your popsicles. If you don’t have the recommended mixers or want to tweak the sweetness and acidity balance, here are some great alternatives:

Fruity Mixers:

• Orange Juice: Substitute with tangerine, grapefruit juice, or even papaya juice for a tropical upgrade.
• Cranberry Juice: Swap in pomegranate juice for deeper flavors.
• Pineapple Juice: Use mango nectar or peach juice for a similar tropical vibe.

Soda Mixers:

• Ginger Beer (for Mule-inspired popsicles): Swap with root beer, ginger ale, or even lemon-lime soda.
• Cola: If cola isn’t available, try Dr Pepper or a cherry soda for a twist.

Sweetened Alternatives:

If simple syrup is unavailable:

• Honey or Agave Syrup: Both are natural sweeteners that dissolve well and bring out richer flavors.
• Stevia Syrup: A great low-calorie sweetener option.

3. Fresh Fruit Substitutes

Adding fresh fruit slices or pulp to your popsicles enhances their visual appeal and provides bursts of flavor. If you don’t have the exact fruit specified in your recipe, here are substitutes:

Citrus Fruits:

• Lime: Use lemon or grapefruit slices for a similar tartness.
• Orange: Swap with mandarin slices for a sweeter version.

Berries:

• Strawberries: Substitute with raspberries or sliced cherries for pops of color and flavor.
• Blueberries: Blackberries or frozen cranberries work well as substitutions.

Tropical Fruits:

• Mango: Substitute with peach chunks or apricots for a similar sweet and juicy flavor.
• Pineapple: Use cantaloupe or honeydew melon for a mellow tropical twist.

Final Thoughts

Making your own Cutwater Popsicles is fun, customizable, and an easy way to bring cocktail vibes to frozen form.

More Recipes:

• Copycat Crowded Kitchen Peanut Butter Eggs Recipe